NW, life’s passage via the Kilburn High Road

The back cover of Zadie Smith’s novel NW, recently long-listed for the Women’s Prize for Fiction 2013 mentions This Is The Story Of A City, the north-west corner of city, however that’s not how I think of it. London is something else, as is The City of London.

NW is a community, a fluid changing community, one of London’s many pulses; for some it is a stepping stone to the next stage, for others it is home. It has been a thoroughfare into London since the days of the Romans and in more recent times, the resting place for Irish immigrants fleeing their country for one reason or another, sometimes dramatic, sometimes not. And following the Irish are the many other groups who found NW their starting point to a life in London, that city of promise and unending challenge. NW is the same, the faces that pass through it, indicative of the era we are living within.

NWNW the novel is experimental, its structure changes with each section and after starting the second part which focuses on Felix, I realised that the narrative voice was being used as a metaphor for the state of mind of the character, a brave step or a risk on the authors part by commencing with Leah, who thoughts are all over the place and is suffering from that anxiety of a young, married woman with a successful career and a husband who loves her, who doesn’t understand why she is not content, or why she can’t admit that she isn’t ready to start a family.

So we start with the staccato stream of conscious thoughts of a woman who would benefit from therapy and/or meditation to still that rampant inner chatter, planting the reader in the midst of prose that is challenging for some and uneasy for those listening to the audio version. Not when chapter 7 is shaped like a tree, though that is one of the least challenging pages, one of beauty in fact.

But once we get to Felix’s section, things calm down, Felix’s major life troubles are behind him, the reading is easy and the pace picks up.  Although he’s not entirely immune to temptation, he seems to have moved on from his more despondent days, he’s been clean for 2 years and plans to stay that way. To me, he is the only character who shows real signs of moving on, however he has not moved out of NW,  his mistake perhaps is in staying and trying to convert those around him.

The other female character Keisha, changes her name to Natalie when she becomes a lawyer, an attempt to outgrow her past; she marries and has two children. She and Leah have been friends since their school days and their connection provides the one strong thread throughout the novel. Natalie, like Leah has risen above her past, but can’t seem to resist undermining it, with her strange behaviour, in what was for me, one of the least believable parts of the novel, in part because the author keeps us from knowing exactly what Natalie is up to online and offline, before she gets caught and flips out. I was hoping she might be more influenced by the role model of  Theodora Lewis-Lane, who tries to advise her.

“The first lesson is: turn yourself down. One notch. Two. Because this is not neutral.”  She passed a hand over her neat frame from her head to her lap, like a scanner. “This is never neutral.”

NW6For me personally, it was in part a nostalgic read, Zadie Smith’s writing comes alive when she evokes place and it is a neighbourhood I lived in and around for many years, NW is the most complete and yet complex character of all, embracing so much diversity, inviting everyone in without prejudice and yet claiming some in the harshest terms possible. There are as many reasons to hate it as there are to love it and anyone who has lived there will likely never forget it.

NW is a melancholic novel about four characters trying to escape their past and leaves the reader with few signs of hope for the future, or at least that future is left for us to imagine. Those who focus on the uniqueness of the writing or who have some experience of /interest in these communities may enjoy it, while those looking for the traditional transformation of character, or any kind of escape may be disappointed.

Despondency is the norm and we will not be rescued from it, it merely lessens with time if we survive.

13 thoughts on “NW, life’s passage via the Kilburn High Road

    • Thanks Valerie, I hope to present it as it is, so that people can decide for themselves and have a realistic idea of what to expect. I don’t like to put anyone off unnecessarily, but also don’t wish to be misleading. I’ve been reading a few interviews which further enlighten us on the direction she is taking with her writing since her last novel, alluded to in the quote I shared at the top of the page. She’s moving away from traditional, accepted forms and seeking a kind of honesty, which makes it somewhat abstract in parts.


  1. Wonderful review, Claire. I liked what you said about the novel depicting the lives of four different characters and how the place they live in is also a character because through the people living in ‘NW’ keep changing, the place is constant. It is also interesting that the novel is experimental – it must be very different in structure when compared to other Zadie Smith novels. I loved Zadie Smith’s novel ‘On Beauty’ and her essay collection ‘Changing My Mind’. I can’t wait to read ‘NW’. Thanks for your wonderful review.


  2. Excellent review Claire. I feel embarrassed that I missed the connection between the experimental section and Leah’s mind state. I saw it as the busy-ness of London (mostly due to that long description of the market) but reading what you’ve written here it makes a lot of sense. It is a strange book, one of those you can’t say exactly why you liked/disliked it.


    • You shouldn’t feel embarrassed Charlie, that is merely my interpretation and one that came to me as I started reading Felix’s section and noticed how calm and easy it was to read through him.

      Perhaps it is because in a way I could relate to Leah and her chattering mind, it reminded me of being 20-something and making myself walk home through the woods to try and bring myself to the present, I recognised the constant chattering mind that would not be silenced and then the more serene one that followed. Normally an author would filter out the unnecessary, but with Leah, Zadie Smith gives us almost everything.

      I read this passage on The Crack in the Tea-Cup Opens blog today and it made me think so much of Zadie Smith’s work:

      Readers can find whatever they want in words, while speakers and writers are left gasping for air. Authors can browbeat their readers into submission, controlling every pen-line until their message is unambiguously plain. It is dangerous to assert that any novel, poem, play or sentence has a certain meaning; everything is open to interpretation and misapprehension. The best that can be hoped for is that on some level the reader can say ‘This is true for me’ – Jenny Metcalfe


  3. Thanks for reviewing another 2 books from the longlist which I will not have a chance to read. NW is a place where I worked occasionally, we have an office there. I was a little uncomfortable walking at Dollis Hill to Willesden Green, but overtime I have got used to it.

    I tried White Teeth but just wasn’t engage enough to keep reading it. I think I will make another attempt at Zadie Smith’s books one day!

    p/s: I was rejected for Life After Life by Kate Atkinson, I am not sure why but I don’t get approval from Little Brown after the Book of Why. 🙂


    • How sad, I think I was in luck because I requested it as soon as it came out (and via the US publisher), I got turned down for The People of Forever are not Afraid by Random House UK because it was only available to those in the “territories” listed. I’m never in the right territory, but fortunately for some that doesn’t really matter, it’s where the reading audience is located that’s more important I would think and mine is US, UK, Canada and France predominantly.


  4. Pingback: Women’s Prize for Fiction Shortlist & Pulitzer Prize 2013 | Word by Word

  5. Pingback: NW by Zadie Smith | JoV's Book Pyramid

  6. Pingback: Transatlantic Journeys, Real and Imagined | Word by Word

  7. Pingback: Swing Time by Zadie Smith #ManBookerPrize – Word by Word

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s