Black Count – Glory, Revolution, Betrayal and the Real Count of Monte Cristo by Tom Reiss

Mention the name Alexandre Dumas and many will associate it with the classic stories as well-known now through their film adaptations, The Count of Monte Cristo, The Three Musketeers, The Black Tulip and La Reine Margot (Marguerite de Valois) as they are through the novels.

In France the novelist referred to as Alexandre Père Dumas, had a son Alexandre, also a well-known playwright. Less is known about the novelist’s father General Alexandre ‘Alex’ Dumas, born in 1762, the son of Marie Cessette Dumas, a black slave from Saint-Domingue (modern-day Haiti) and a French nobleman Alexandre Antoine Davy, the Marquis de Pailleterie, who was from a family of provincial aristocrats with a more impressive coat of arms and title than fortune to their name.

Tom Reiss has researched the life of General Alex Dumas and takes us from the French sugar plantations of Saint-Domingue to the battlefields of the French revolution and to a dark dungeon on an island in the Mediterranean, in recapturing the spirit of this extraordinary man, living in an unforgettable era, that we are all the better off for being reminded of.

Antoine was the eldest of three brothers, required to go out in the world and seek their fortunes, which they initially pursue in the army before Antoine followed his brother Charles to Saint-Domingue. At the time the world’s largest sugar exporter, it generated vast wealth using slave labour, as depicted so vividly by Isabelle Allende in her excellent novel Beneath the Sea.

Charles married into money and established himself as a planter so Antoine joined him, though without the same work ethic or ambition, content to live off his brother, until an altercation caused him to flee with a couple of slaves and his slave mistress. The brothers never saw each other again and the family lost track of the eldest brother believing him to be dead. As the eldest, Antoine was heir to the title and the ancestral estate of Bielleville, however it was passed to a nephew in the belief of his demise, until his sudden and unexpected return to France.

Antoine had fled across the mountains to Jérémie, a coffee plantation area where he settled with a woman named Marie-Cessette and had four children with, including a son born on March 25, 1762 whom they named Thomas-Alexandre.

Bielleville, the family estate

He eventually returned to France, and learning of the death of his parents attempted to claim his title which had passed to the nephew, Comte Léon de Maulde, who employed a detective to investigate the returning heir’s mysterious island interlude and return.

Chauvinault then reported on Antoine’s having bought, in the late 1750’s, the beautiful black woman named Marie-Cessette, for whom he’d paid that “exorbitant price” – implying some unusual interest in her. Before Antoine’s return to France, Chauvinault reported, he had sold three of his children, as well as Marie-Cessette herself.

The detective also brought the interesting news that Antoine’s fourth child, a boy who was said to be his favourite, had not been sold along with the others. This boy was “a young mulatto who, it is said, was sold at Port-au-Prince,” Chauvinaluth wrote, “conditionally, with the right of redemption, to Captain Langlois, for 800 livres.”

On arrival in France Antoine sends for his son and thus begins a different life for the adolescent Alex Dumas Davy de la Pailleterie. His father pawned the family estate and moved them to the rich and fast growing Saint-Germain-en-Laye, on the western side of Paris. Dumas received a superior education, expensive clothes, training in fine manners, riding, baroque dancing and duelling among other equally refined activities. After a falling out with his father, he enlisted as a horseman in the service of the queen just as the French revolution was gaining ascendancy, which resulted in him being promoted through the ranks rapidly, rising to command entire divisions.

Up until the reign of Napoleon Bonaparte, nothing seemed to phase Dumas, he was respected by all, he was fair, he introduced many improvements in the armies beneath him and challenged any wrongdoings of others, whilst keeping his head – not so easy during the reign of terror.

General Alex Dumas

Alex Dumas was a consummate warrior but also a man of great conviction and moral courage. He was renowned for his strength, his swordsmanship, his bravery, and his knack for pulling victory out of the toughest situations. But he was known, too, for his profane back talk and his problems with authority.

Alexandre Pere Dumas, Novelist

He was the inspiration behind the hero of his son’s novel ‘The Count of Monte Cristo‘, the story of the young sailor Edmond Dantes who, on the verge of a promising career and life, is locked away without witness or trial in the dungeon of the island fortress Château d’If.

An island dungeon is where Alex Dumas, finds himself after the failed French invasion of Egypt, when he is almost shipwrecked on his return, the ship limping into the south of Italy, which in the meantime has become an enemy of France and sadly Dumas’ influence with Bonaparte has diminished and he is all but forgotten.

Les Fers brisés, Paris

The story is rich in detail and reads more like a novel than the historical account that it is. Tom Reiss has excelled in researching both the vast volume of documentation, which from his account, sounds as if the Generals sent letters at an equivalent rate to which people send email today as well as visiting all of the battle sites and physical locations the General and his family were based.

Reiss encounters his own difficulties in pursuing the research, all of which contribute to making this a most compelling and entertaining read, but above all, one can’t help but admire the man, who lived in an extraordinary period of history, who was born into slavery, witnessed its emancipation, then both saw and experienced it tragically being rescinded. He deserves his rightful place in the historical annals of France, as a role model, a hero and a man of the people.

Note: This book was an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) kindly made available by the publisher via NetGalley.

15 thoughts on “Black Count – Glory, Revolution, Betrayal and the Real Count of Monte Cristo by Tom Reiss

  1. It’s an amazing story, isn’t it? I only found out this summer about the Dumas family roots (including black roots) – and he was one of my ‘must reads’ when I was a child. Just goes to show how we often got to hear only the ‘official versions’ of history, biography and so on. Thanks for doing such a great job of presenting it!


    • Totally fascinating and much underrated, but good to know there continues to exist a lobby to rectify and acknowledge the significance of his contribution to the revolution and to equality among all humanity regardless of race.

      Les Fers, the slave irons sculpture pictured was created in his honour, but there remains pressure to replace the statue that was destroyed by the Nazi’s during the war. I agree, he was a hero and a General, not just a slave.


  2. Claire please advise: What should I do? Read Count of Monte Cristo first….or The Black Count? I have both of these books here in my bookcase!


    • You should read The Black Count first I would suggest and then you might even consider Georges, a lesser known novel of Dumas which he published before The Count of Monte Cristo, creating a protagonist based on his father who was also half black, however sadly the French reading public weren’t quite ready for the mixed race hero and it has been suggested that he then created the more politically correct white protagonist Edward Dantes, in the later novel, which as we know was a great success. But definitely meet the man before you are introduced to the character he inspires. You won’t regret it.


  3. Dumas wrote very interesting novels which I have watched movies and read about them when I was a young child. it would be great to read one of his novel as an adult. Recent example was The Phantom of the Opera. despite how many times I have heard the songs and mentioned in Lloyd webber’s long running west end play, I have never watched them. But I was blown away by the book! It reads like thriller.

    Thanks for the intro on Dumas.


  4. Claire, a fascinating review of a fascinating subject. How one’s heart burns as one reads of these people who trusted the father, being sold as slaves… I actually wanted to know more about them too, did they end their lives as slaves… oh dear, – history hurts sometimes doesn’t it.


    • I know what you mean Valerie, to know that we would have to ask the author, I suspect it isn’t known what happened to them, although the name of the buyer was mentioned in the book, so who knows, perhaps some record exists somewhere. Even what the General experiences having risen so high to see it all unravel, is such a travesty, the cruelty of man seems to know few limits.


  5. Oh Claire, how my “must read” list grows. I want to find a quiet space in the south of France and spend a year simply reading (okay … and perhaps writing about it … ). Right now I feel I am reading vicariously through you and don’t know how you find the time to read, absorb, and share in such a meaningful way with your faithful followers. Merci mille fois!


  6. Pingback: Top Reads 2012 | Word by Word

  7. A fascinating period of history which I know very little about. I’ve not come across very much French literature, or history, and I think this is something I want to fix very soon! Thank you for the recommendation, my reading list grows and grows!


    • Likewise and I am fast trying to rectify it now that I live here! But it is fascinating and I love a writer whose work reads like a novel. This inspired me to read more in French as well, it’s so slow going but so rewarding.


  8. Pingback: Women’s Prize for Fiction Shortlist & Pulitzer Prize 2013 | Word by Word

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s