If Beale Street Could Talk by James Baldwin

If Beale Street Could Talk is the first work by James Baldwin that I have read. It was the first work he wrote after he moved to St Paul de Vence in the south of France, where he would pass the last 17 years of his life.

He also wrote his first two novels at the beginning of his literary career, Go Tell It on the Mountain and Giovanni’s Room, along with his best-known collection of essays, Notes of a Native Son during a nine-year period he lived in Paris.

When Jordan Elgrably of The Paris Review asked why he left the United States said:

I was broke. I got to Paris with forty dollars in my pocket, but I had to get out of New York. My reflexes were tormented by the plight of other people. Reading had taken me away for long periods at a time, yet I still had to deal with the streets and the authorities and the cold. My luck was running out. I was going to go to jail, I was going to kill somebody or be killed. My best friend had committed suicide two years earlier, jumping off the George Washington Bridge.

He found it increasingly difficult to be a witness to life in America so perhaps France provided him the distance from which to write. With Beale Street he was able to immerse in a love story, bringing out the emotional bonds that keep a family together, that give them something extra, to not just survive, but overcome the harsh, unjust realities of everyday life in America for black people.

The novel revolves around childhood sweethearts, 19-year-old Tish and 22-year-old Fonny. We meet them as she visits him in prison.

I don’t know why people always look down when they talk through a telephone, but they always do. You have to remember to look up at the person you’re talking to.

I always remember now, because he’s in jail and I love his eyes and every time I see him I’m afraid I’ll never see him again. So I pick up the phone as soon as I’m there and I keep looking up at him.

Interspersed with the regular visits, are flash-backs to childhood and the moment their friendship evolved to something deeper. Fonny takes Tish to his basement pad where he has set up a woodwork studio, his deepest passion is sculpting wood and stone, he wants to show her and for her to understand its importance to him.

After asking her to marry him, they’d looked for loft space together, they were planning a future together, when suddenly robbed of it by a false accusation.  His alibi’s are discredited and he sinks into despair, but for her visits.

Though heartbroken, she is emboldened by her family, by the adamant support of her sister, who finds them a good lawyer, her mother, who travels to Porto Rico to confront the accuser, and her father, who works extra shifts to raise funds for Fonny’s bail.

It is the words, actions and support of the family that keep everyone from falling apart, they are a stalwart to Fonny especially, as his family crack under the pressure of a mother converted to a conservative faith prone to judgement and disappointment, more concerned about her own reputation than the innocence of her son.

It is interesting that Baldwin chose to narrate the novel from Tish’s perspective, and though it may have provoked criticism, it is perhaps one injustice that he sought to right – allowing the voice of a young black woman to rise and be heard.

Sharon, her mother, was a fabulous character. So in touch with her deepest roots, she is able to appease her daughter when she fearfully shares news of her pregnancy:

‘Tish’, she said, ‘when we was first brought here, the white man he didn’t give us no preachers to say words over us before we had our babies. And you and Fonny be together right now, married or not, wasn’t, wasn’t for that same damn white man. So let me tell you what you got to do. You got to think about that baby. You got to hold onto that baby, don’t care what else happens or doesn’t happen. You got to do that. Can’t nobody else do that for you. And the rest of us, well, we going to hold on to you. And we going to get Fonny out. Don’t you worry. I know it’s hard – but don’t you worry. And that baby be the best thing that ever happened to Fonny. He needs that baby. It going to give a whole lot of courage.’

Right there, the mother reinforces stability in their lives and I can’t help but be aware of the contrast, having just read the memoir An Affair With My Mother of a baby conceived within a culture that shame(s)d its daughters for pregnancy outside of wedlock, destroying lives, dividing families, creating unnecessary drama. This action and steadfast support by Sharon is a protest against the inherent culture and inherited religious beliefs, over which love and the family bond will prevail. It is a powerful matriarchal triumph, one that reaches far back in ancestral memory.

So the family encounter difficult circumstances and yet their ability to be there for each other sees them though and even Fonny is swept up in this wave of support, nourished by it, even though he has moments of sliding into darkness, as is human. By contrast, his family is fragmented, the mother and daughters reject the offer of unity offered by Joseph and Sharon, the father Frank gets it and tries to support them, to be part of this newly extended family, but without the strength of an unconditional bond within his own, he is left vulnerable.

James Baldwin in France

I think Baldwin succeeds if it was his intention to write about the powerful effect of love and family, in their ability to carry each other through difficult times, when they refuse to resort to blame (of themselves or others) or judgement, when they hold each other up and decide to be a force together and not give in to destructive tendencies.

I’ve just seen the film at our local cinema. It’s challenging to watch to a film you are still reflecting on reading.

In a recent interview, Director Barry Jenkins talked about Baldwin’s work:

I chose Beale Street because I felt the novel, more than any of his other works, represented the perfect blend of Baldwin’s dual obsessions with romance and social critique, as sensual a depiction of love as it is a biting observation of systemic injustice.

I thought the movie was a beautiful and moving depiction of the story, although my big takeaways from the book about that family bond, (especially the mother to the daughter) weren’t as strong in the film. Some of the most important lines I’d noted (and went back to check) were taken from the mother and given to the father, which surprised me, as it shifted the dynamic and removed what for me had been a significant and empowering statement coming from the mother (supported by the father). Passing those lines to the father risked putting the mother back into a supporting role, and lessened the matriarchal force Baldwin imbued her with.

The other significant moment in the book for me, which I’m not sure comes across in the film with quite the same impact, is a moment near the end where there is a change in Fonny, observed here by Tish, which you’ll have to read to find out more:

“- something quite strange, altogether wonderful, happens in him…”

All the more reason, even if you’ve seen the film, to get a copy of the book! And all that said, I’d recommend both without hesitation.

Buy a Copy of Beale Street via Book Depository

Have you read James Baldwin? Do you have a favourite?

20 thoughts on “If Beale Street Could Talk by James Baldwin

  1. I loved both the film and the book, but I was surprised by the differences too. I also thought that the film handled the confrontation with Victoria Rogers in Puerto Rico with more wisdom about her than Baldwin himself did. But they’re both great pieces of art.

    The great thing about Baldwin is that he creates such hermetic, unique worlds in each of his books, so different from on another. I found Go Tell It on the Mountain very, very different from both Beale Street and Giovanni’s Room, but all are works of art. And his essays are brilliant too. Obviously, I am a fan!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. As far as I can recall, I’ve only read Giovanni’s Room which was some time ago but I remember being very taken with it. As for the changes, I must say they sound unnecessary, particularly in this day and age. Such a shift of emphasis would really change the impact of the story…


  3. Wow! What a great review! I have not read this one. The Fire Next Time is amazing and I loved G’s Room. I love the bold and powerful way Baldwin puts the words together. I get this one too. Thanks a lot for the comprehensive review!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I’m so glad you enjoyed this, Claire. I thought Jenkins captured the lyricism, power and beauty of Baldwin’s prose so effectively through the medium of film. It’s rare for a film to complement a book so effectively, but I felt this was true in this instance (though I must admit that I hadn’t picked up on the transfer of some lines from Tish’s mother to her father).

    If you’re looking for more suggestions on some of Baldwin’s other books, I can thoroughly recommend his novel, Another Country – another very powerful read.


  5. Ah I’m reading this at the moment so I’m glad it’s getting positive reviews! I loved Giovanni’s Room by Baldwin, if you’re looking for more recs 🙂 Thanks for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Excellent review, Claire. Looking forward to reading this, along with seeing the movie, a bit later in the year. Baldwin’s one of my favorite writers, though I’ve read more of his nonfiction than fiction. “Sonny’s Blues” is a moving short story about a fraught bond between two brothers, should you ever be interested in reading more of his work.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I’m been reading stories and essays of his. I agree with Jack Messenger above re: “Going to Meet the Man.” “Sonny’s Blues” is a particularly masterful story. And the New Yorker ran a piece from its archives, “Later from a Region of My Mind,” that’s chilling in the way it reminds us the times in which we’re living. Re: the movie, I agree that was lyrical, but I found it lacking in some compelling aspects of the novel, especially its ending.


  8. Really enjoyed the movie a lot more than I had anticipated. I read the book 3 or 4 years a go and really loved it too. I like how they ended the movie. I wasn’t expecting that at all. Fonnie and Tish are definitely an iconic literary couple. Nothing like young love….

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Pingback: Winding up the Week #58 – Book Jotter

  10. Pingback: If Beale Street Could Talk by James Baldwin – A must read. | Book Around The Corner

  11. I find your review very interesting and spot on.
    I’ve seen the film before finishing the book, so I didn’t notice all the changes you mention.

    I thought the film was beautiful and the atmosphere faithful to the book. The scenes between Tish and Fonny are beautifully filmed, the way they look at each other and convey their feeling. Very well done.


  12. Pingback: Women’s Prize for Fiction Winner 2019 – An American Marriage by Tayari Jones – Word by Word

  13. Pingback: The Fire Next Time by James Baldwin – Word by Word

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s