Bitter Orange by Claire Fuller

This is Claire Fuller’s third book and is as engaging as her previous two, her unforgettable debut Our Endless Numbered Days which slowly unravels the story behind a 17-year-old girl who is back with her family after she went missing for nine years and last years Swimming Lessons, which also involved a mysterious disappearance, but was more of a portrait of a marriage.

Bitter Orange is less mysterious and though it is set in 1969, it has something of the feel of a timeless classic, with its setting in a dilapidated English mansion, with two characters employed by the new, absent owner to make a report on the inventory and architecture of the interior and garden, people interested in old things from the past, haunted by them in fact.

The book opens with Frances, unmarried, twenty years after certain events, as she is nearing the end of her life, recounting moments of that summer she spent at the country house to a vicar, the same vicar who was present that summer, witness to some but not all of what occurred. He seems eager to fill in the missing details, to elicit a confession of sorts, while there is still the opportunity.

Frances was there to document details about what was believed might be a Palladian bridge, however it was so overgrown, that she wasn’t convinced there was anything of interest beneath the plant life that was strangling the edifice.

Once settled into her attic room, France spies her housemates, Cara the carefree young woman, who it soon becomes clear is tormented by something and Peter the older lover of antiquities, a man who more than admires, wishes to possess all that he finds alluring.

Though Frances feels like an outsider around this couple, largely friendless having spent years looking after her elderly mother, she responds with great pleasure and anticipation to their invitations and soon the three of them abandon their responsibilities and spend their days like summer guests, plundering the champagne stocks they’ve discovered, picnicking  and enjoying the fruits and uncovered fortune of the environment they’ve occupied just like the armies that came before them.

The longer they spend together, the more it is obvious to Frances that their stories don’t correlate and that something is not right. Rather than confront them, she wants to continue being part of the trio they’ve become, a mistake that will cost her dearly.

In their unobserved curiosity, they cross forbidden boundaries, they participate in and witness activities that entangle their lives, pushing them over the edge from minor misdemeanors into irreconcilable behaviours that will change their lives forever.

For me, it didn’t have the same captivating atmosphere, characterisation and thought-provoking aspects present in Swimming Lessons, which is my favourite of the three books and was a five-star read for me last year, however it excels in demonstrating the murky depths of people, who are often not what they seem on the surface, and even when unravelled and revealed may not be telling things as they really are or were. Yes, watch out for the unreliable narrator,.

Fuller succeeds in penetrating the dark, murky aspects of character in a disturbing ending that surprises, given the elevated perception they have tried to portray themselves as, until that bewitching, bitter end.

N.B. Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy.

Buy a Copy of one of Claire Fuller’s books via Book Depository

12 thoughts on “Bitter Orange by Claire Fuller

    • Yes, for me Swimming Lessons was the one I didn’t want to put down, her first novel was full of intrigue, and this feels like she’s getting into her stride, 3 books in. It feels like she experiments with a hint of mystery in each book, but it was the insight into character in the second book that really made it rise above the others. I almost feel like she doesn’t need the element of mystery, it confuses the intention, especially as it arrives so late.


  1. Like Cathy, I haven’t read anything by Claire Fuller, but her novels do seem to have garnered some excellent reviews.

    Have you read The Go-Between by L.P. Hartley? I ask because another reviewer or tweeter (I can’t recall which) likened Bitter Orange to the Hartley, probably because of the setting. This heightened my interest in hearing more about it as The Go-Between is a favourite book.


    • I don’t know that book, I wonder if it in any way inspired Claire Fuller? I love that opening line : “The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there.”

      Thanks for mentioning it Jacqui, I’ll add it to the list for potential summer reads!


  2. Great review – a ‘timeless classic’ is a great description for this. Her books all seem so very different. I read and enjoyed Our Endless Numbered Days so will have to pick up Swimming Lessons.
    Lynn 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Our Endless Numbered Days by Claire Fuller – Word by Word

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s